Wednesday, May. 30, 2012

Maple Leaf Logos – Can we Stop This?

Written By:

|

Friday, July 29, 2011

|

Posted In:

The big news of the week was, once again, the Winnipeg Jets who have dominated the attention of the sports logo world this Summer (and just when you thought we were done covering the new Jets identity remember, we’re still waiting for the new uniforms…)

The logo of the Royal Canadian Air Force, the inspiration for the new Winnipeg Jets logo

Reactions to the new Winnipeg Jets logos were a mixed bag – divided amongst those who focus on judging a logo for it’s design versus those who look at it’s inspiration.  The Jets honouring the Royal Canadian Air Force in their logo is a nice tribute, even if True North had to slap their own mark on the long-respected Canadian military symbol.

When I first saw the new logo I hated that notch in the top of the logo pointing to the north, I still do, I also hated the maple leaf behind the jet.  Over the last few days I’ve accepted a maple leaf on the primary logo, honour a national branch of the military with a national symbol – okay, I get it. The maple leaf in the alternate/secondary logo is a must, it looks great on there, the best look of the bunch.

Now as for that script logo? Eh… not so much.

"Put a leaf on it! That way they'll know we're Canadian!"

I touched upon this earlier in the week but I just knew deep down that this set would have a maple leaf slapped in wherever possible, that’s the thing now, the marketing staff for most new teams in Canada apparently say “put a maple leaf in the logo, doesn’t matter if it looks good or matches the colour scheme – just do it!”

A red leaf on a black, silver and blue uniform... makes sense

You can see examples of this slapped-on maple leaf strategy on that Jets script logo, on the sleeves of the uniforms of the Toronto Blue Jays (despite there being no red at all in their colour scheme), the logos of the Toronto Rock, Mississauga Ice Dogs and Ottawa Renegades among others.

"Slapped on leaf" offendersTop Row: Toronto Rock and Ontario Raiders (NLL), Mississauga Ice Dogs (OHL). Bottom Row: Ottawa Renegades (CFL), Oshawa Dodgers and Hamilton Thunderbirds (IBL)

To me this is one of the worst trends in new brands – I consider it borderline insulting as a sports fan, a design fan and a Canadian.  Do they think we’re idiots?  Do they think we’re incapable of supporting a team if we don’t see a maple leaf on there reminding us that, yup, they’re a Canadian team, as if the fact they list a Canadian city right on the logo means nothing.

This trend isn't exclusive to minor-league teams... the Toronto Blue Jays and Toronto Raptors are both guilty of this

Then again, maybe we are idiots – when the Toronto Blue Jays launched the first logo in franchise history to not have a maple leaf in it the public lost their minds. Jays then-President Paul Godfrey shot back with “sorry, we couldn’t stick every colour in the rainbow in the logo”.  Nice.  But despite Paul’s best efforts to restore sanity the team put the maple leaf on their sleeve as soon as Mr. Godfrey left the club.

So now we’ll wait for the next team to end up in Canada so we can see the latest and greatest way they shove a maple leaf in there – what’s that? The next new team might be in Quebec? Okay, we’ll wait for the one after the next one.

Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m off to McDonald’s for breakfast…

Nevermind.

 

 

Share This Article

Related News

Mississauga Steelheads Unveil New Logo
Camo Caps to be worn by all MLB Teams, Full Gallery Here
Photos of Orioles, Pirates in Camouflage Uniforms

About Author

Chris Creamer

Chris Creamer is the founder of SportsLogos.Net and has been maintaining it since June 1997. You can follow him on Twitter at @sportslogosnet

(22) Readers Comments

  1. Prison Mike
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 09:07

    Don't forget the stylized Maple Leaf on the Toronto FC badge, and the slapped-on Canadian flags on the sleeves for TFC and Vancouver Whitecaps (though US flags are on the US-based teams in equally insulting fashion).

  2. Mike Ivall Design
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 09:09

    Well the AHL St.John's is coming out today. the name sounds like it will be the Ice caps. How much you want to bet there will be a iced up maple leaf in there.

  3. Math
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 09:32

    I do agree with you, but did you check YOUR primary logo ;) a lot of maple leaves on this page...

    • Chris Creamer
      Friday, July 29, 2011 at 10:00

      @Math - The difference is my maple leaf isn't slapped into the design almost as an afterthought like many of the above examples are (Winnipeg script, Mississauga IceDogs are great examples)

  4. Gregg French
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 09:57

    I'm approaching 50, my parents are from Montreal and I've been visiting Canada my whole life. The "slap a leaf on it" strategy has been a part of corporate Canada for DECADES. If I were to guess, my guess would be that it's because the Canadian flag itself has only existed since the mid-60s. Departments stores in nowheresville had souvenir sections. I assume that's because Canadians were, themselves, still struck by the novelty of that big red leaf. That McDonald's logo was the first example that jumped into my mind, but LOTS of logos familiar to U.S. consumers have a leaf added to them in Canada. I guess in the past 45 years or so "slap a leaf on it" has become a habit that can't be broken.

  5. pmichaelb
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 12:07

    I actually thought the same thing when I first saw the Jets logo. This article is right on. Because so few Canadian cities have teams in major pro sports (relatively speaking) I can appreciate the desire teams have to celebrate their uniqueness in that way, but it's becoming quite cliche.

  6. Jack
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 12:20

    I think it would look way better if they put the script somewhere on the primary logo. Off Topic: Chris, why is your soccer section called "Fußball"?

    • Chris Creamer
      Friday, July 29, 2011 at 12:22

      @Jack - It shows up as Fußball on the site for you because you are located in Germany (at least your IP is)

  7. Kris
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 12:27

    To defend the Jays and Raptors, they are Canada's only team in their respective leagues. Toronto FC is also Canada's first MLS team.

  8. Brian
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 17:57

    CC, Ive noticed it too within the past 15 years or so. Im from Michigan and Like a lot of Canadian teams especially hockey ones. The Jays and Flames shoulder patches is too much. especially the Jays. I own more Jays merchandise then my beloved Tigers because ive always like their colors. I wont buy a blue black and grey jersey with a red maple leaf on the sleeve though.

  9. D-Man
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 19:37

    It similar to a team in Texas having a Star

  10. bleuet
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 21:37

    Like I wrote on the forum, too many maple leaves everywhere on canadian pro teams. The case of the Jets is a good exemple. Why a maple leaf? Its the Jets, not the canadian jets, or the RCAF hockey team. Do the NY Jets have a star on their logo? The Capitals play in the US capital city, they can have stars. Except the Jackets ans the Stars, for obvious reasons, name a US NHL team wearing stars? The MLB Nationals don't have any reference to the stars and stripes! Find one european pro rugby or soccer team wearing a logo with this type of national reference. Canadians dont need to see leaves on their pro teams logo to remind themselves they are canadian. This give weapons to those who say canadian do not have any pride.

  11. nathan
    Friday, July 29, 2011 at 21:37

    The calgary flames slapped a canadian flag and an alberta flag on their unis a few seasons back. Makes little sense as they are niether the only canadian or albertan nhl team

  12. Mark Dewdney
    Saturday, July 30, 2011 at 11:48

    That Jets logo would be fine on the shoulders, but hey - if they bowed to pressure on the overall name of the team, can't we pressure them into the old-school logo? After all, it's not REALLY a throwback to the REAL Jets (and a proper slap to Bettman's face) unless it has the old logo...

  13. Douglas Malicote
    Monday, August 1, 2011 at 11:43

    My Uncle lives in Canada

  14. Mr. BigCar
    Monday, August 1, 2011 at 13:54

    let me through the use of fleur-de-lis for formerly French American cities, teams in NOLA (obviously), St. Louis, Louisville, Montreal, Quebec are all guilty, perhaps next year's MLS Montreal Impact can go for the fleur-de-lis/maple leaf combo..fleur-de-leaf!

  15. Crootz
    Monday, August 1, 2011 at 18:31

    Great article, couldn't agree more. Put it this way, there are 7 Canadian NHL teams and 3 have a leaf as part of their uniform (Leafs, Jets and Flames) 2 are named after Canada (Canadiens and Canucks) and the Senators used to have a shoulder logo with a leaf on it. Only 1 team did not have some direct representation to Canada, and thats Edmonton. Just seems cliche and even tacky most of the time to force national pride on a uniform, I think we're a little bit smarter than this.

  16. Jeremiah
    Monday, August 1, 2011 at 21:18

    Listen, you should feel pride in the Maple Leaf. You have absolutely no case compared to native americans who have logos mocking them (Cleveland Indians, North Dakota Fighting Sioux, and even the racist Washington Redskins), so I don't wanna hear about how sick you are of seeing the Maple leaf in Canadian sports logos. Shut up and be happy your country even gets professional sports teams, you ungrateful canuck.

    • Chris Creamer
      Monday, August 1, 2011 at 22:47

      @Jeremiah... Judging by your response I'm not surprised that you'd miss the point entirely. Times are that bad for you in Des Moines? Anyone who wants to contact Jeremiah about his response can do so at jmiah45@hotmail.com. Cheers

  17. Jim Quealy
    Tuesday, August 2, 2011 at 16:20

    Dont forget about the logos for Air Canada, Molson, Labatt's, etc, etc, etc. We know---you're from Canada!

  18. bleuet
    Tuesday, August 2, 2011 at 18:27

    Its not a matter of proudness or whatever. Its a matter of originality. Theres no point in wearing leaves when everybody know you are from Canada. Its an admission of inferiority. We need to put leaves to show we are in Canada? This is stupid, not original, not creative. How come the Winnipeg Jets have maple leaves everywhere? If TNSE really wanted to go the way they wanted, I would have put the F-18 very alike jet in the roundel with no maple leaf that blurr and confuse the whole thing. I just don't like it period. And you are right, the MTL Impact should not have fleur de lys on their unis. The QC Nordiques will because QC is the capital of the province..

  19. jeason
    Tuesday, August 16, 2011 at 01:28

    The new JAY uniforms from 2004 tried to attract Americans in buying Toronto merchandise as well without having the maple leaf I'm all for that. Raptors ditches purple and made the red primary colour. Then a few years later they got the leaf on their neck collar. It's fine for Toronto cuz they try to differentiate them selves from Americans by using the leaf. Cuz Toronto is an American city stuck in Canada. I love all the teams in t-dot except the leafs cuz they embarrass the country and I'm a huge Habs fan, which makes me entirely canadien! I have a derozen, wells from last year, and alouetts I dig the leafs. Alouetts no leaf? Yes! Check the logo ears out! Those are leafs!

Leave A Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>